How To Shop For The Best Crib Sheets (Plus Review)

How To Shop For The Best Crib Sheets (Plus Review)

One of the best moments you will enjoy when shopping for your newborn is looking for crib sheets. The baby will spend most of the first days sleeping. So, their sleeping space has to be soothing, comfortable and appealing enough. It does not have to cost you a fortune as long as you have an idea on how to shop for the best crib sheets.

When you hit the market, you will find a wide array of choices. These come in various patterns, colors, sizes, and materials. Without proper information, all these options might be overwhelming when trying to find the best for your baby.

There are many bedding sets which might look very appealing with their colors and styles. However, not all will match your child’s needs.

Options available

There are four kinds of crib sheets. Each comes with its pros and cons. So, you need to have information about them before making a decision.

Cotton sheets

These make a more decent and standard quality for crib sheets. Pure cotton is safer, breathable and soft. It helps to keep your baby cool regardless of the period of the year.

Crib sheets are hypoallergenic which makes them safe for your child even when suffers from skin irritation or allergies. They are soft, durable and convenient to wash. You will love cotton sheets since they are easy to keep clean and look nice. It is because they do not attract lint.

Polyester sheets

Polyester is a synthetic material used in crib sheets. These are cheaper than cotton sheets.  Technological advancement in the textile industry has made it possible to make polyester a viable and safer alternative for crib sheets. You will discover that satin and microfiber sheets are made from 100 percent polyester.

Crib sheets made of polyester are more budget-friendly, resists wrinkle and tear plus being less susceptible to shrinks.

Flannel sheets

For better protection for your baby in winter, flannel sheets are a better option. These can trap warmth very well. So, it helps to keep the baby warm when it is so cold outside. You have to understand that flannel varies according to the manufacturing process. Some contain a mixture of cotton, synthetics or wool. Ensure to check its ingredients before making a purchase.

The best thing about flannel is the ability to be lightweight which makes them suitable for use as crib sheets. These sheets are durable and get softer with every wash.

Alternate natural fiber sheets

Companies have started offering sheets made from a natural fiber like bamboo without using cotton. These appeal to parents who are environmentally conscious. Though these sheets are organic, they cannot keep up with cotton regarding durability and comfort.

The best thing about natural fiber sheets is being environmentally friendly and being hypoallergenic.

Best crib sheets review

Below is our review of some of the top crib sheet brands in the market. Read on to help you get an idea of what to look for when in the market for baby crib sheets.

American Baby Company Heavenly Soft Chenille Fitted Crib Sheet


Though made of polyester, they are of outstanding quality. Mothers love them for being soft and durable. Heavenly crib sheets come in 22 colors with patterns for boys and girls. Your baby will sleep safely since they fit snugly on any standard 28 by 52 inches crib mattress.

These sheets will keep your baby warmer in colder weather better than cotton sheets. Heavenly sheets hold warmth very well. They have a sturdy material which allows them to stand repeated washing without fear of tear or piling.

You too will love these highly rated sheets on Amazon for keeping your baby sleeping snugly, warmly and safely.


  • Fit snugly
  • Durable
  • No flame retardant
  • Variety of colors
  • Soft and cozy
  • check-circle
    No shrinking


  • Elasticity does not last forever
American Baby Company Heavenly Soft Chenille Fitted Crib Sheet for Standard Crib and Toddler Mattresses, Pink
  • SOFT. Perhaps the softest most velvety crib sheet your baby will ever snuggle on.
  • QUALITY. Snug fit with 9" deep pockets and elastic trim to hug a standard crib mattress. Machine washable.
  • 100% Velvety Polyester. Measures 28 inches x 52 inches x 9 inches.

Last update on 2017-12-17 at 01:43 PST - Details

Magnolia Organics Printed Crib Sheet


Made from 100 percent organic cotton, Magnolia crib sheets are colorful and comfortable. They are made of cotton which is weaved into soft and thick fabric to give your newborn a comfortable sleep. These sheets also come in various colors to give your baby nursery a great look.

With colors and patterns made with eco-friendly pigments, Magnolia sheets are certified to meet Global Organic Textile Standards. It includes their packaging as well. These sheets come in 28 by 52 by 9 inches which is suitable to fit any standard crib mattress.

These kinds of sheets have a thread count of 300 and are from a sateen material which is great to touch. It ensures your baby is comfortable. The best thing is that Magnolia crib sheets are in reusable bags made from organic cotton too.

Magnolia sheets are a great option for green parents. They are eco-friendly all the way from the manufacturing process as well. Even the dyes used are environmentally friendly.


  • Very warm
  • Durable
  • No shrinking after drying
  • Dryer safe
  • Budget-friendly
  • check-circle
    Environmentally friendly


  • Bunches up when baby turns
  • times-circle
    A bit rough and scratchy after a couple of washes
Magnolia Organics Printed Crib Sheet, 300 Thread Count Sateen - Standard, Wheat Elephant
  • 100% Organic Cotton
  • Eco-Friendly Manufacturing Process
  • Standard Fitted Sheet Measures 28" x 52" x 9"
  • 300 Thread Count Sateen
  • Packed in a reusable organic cotton accessories bag

Last update on 2017-12-17 at 01:43 PST - Details

Where the Polka Dots Roam sheets

These crib sheets are made of soft microfiber fabric to offer the ultimate comfort your baby deserves. Where the Polka Dots Roam crib sheets come in super cute designs which will delight any parent or baby. You can get these sheets in bright colored animal patterns. These will make great accents for a zoo theme in the baby nursery.

It is so easy to care for these sheets. A machine wash plus tumble dry will get them looking new. Polka Dot sheets will not shrink or become unfit even after years of use. You will not have to worry about corners slipping off the mattress. These sheets fit any standard 52 inches mattress.

With a thread count of 1500, these crib sheets are so soft. It makes them incredibly comfortable for your baby to sleep on. The child will also stay warm in winter and cool in summer. If you are not satisfied, the company offers a 100 percent money back guarantee with no questions asked.


  • Cute
  • No wrinkles
  • Durability
  • Fit snugly
  • Soft
  • check-circle
    No piling
  • check-circle


  • Better off with solid colors
  • times-circle
    Not thick enough
  • times-circle
    Bunches with an active child

Muslin Cotton Baby Crib Sheets

There are the softest and most comfortable sheets you can get for your baby. Made from colorful muslin cotton, Pretty Baby sheets get softer with every wash. They are made from 100 percent muslin cotton which makes them breathable. It helps to keep your newborn comfortable.

These muslin sheets have 9 inches pockets where the crib mattress fits securely. It prevents the sheets from sliding off the bed. They are also made to fit a standard crib mattress. Cleaning Pretty Baby muslin baby sheets is so easy. You just have to toss them into a washing machine with warm water.

You will love the cute bright prints of these sheets. They work well for boys and girls when looking at creating a fun and cheery bed for your newborn. These sheets are cool during summers and cool in winter. It guarantees comfort for your baby all year round.


  • Breathable
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Deep pocket to fit mattress
  • Cute
  • Comfortable
  • Good quality


  • Does not fit on pack n play
  • Might rip after a few washes

Crib sheet buyer guide

You need ideas on the best way to pick the best sheets for your baby’s crib. In the review above, it is time to make up your mind on which brand of sheets to purchase for your child.

Fabrics used

You need crib sheets which will make your baby sleep comfortably. Crib sheets which are 100 percent cotton will be gentle and soft on your baby’s skin. They offer a cool environment for the baby’s skin to breathe. Cotton sheets will absorb moisture and wetness better than those made from other material.

Sheets made from 100 percent polyester resist wrinkles and water. Polyester is a synthetic fabric with high resistance to moisture. There are also other kinds made from a combination of cotton and polyester fabrics. Your baby will enjoy the pros of both fabrics.


It is a great good idea to get hypoallergenic sheets for your child. You have to avoid crib sheets with fibers which might trigger allergic reactions. You can notice allergies using symptoms like swelling of the face, red eyes, difficulty in breathing, and skin rashes.

Always choose sheets made from organic fibers to avoid such incidences.

Free from toxic substances

Stay away from crib sheets which might contain toxic substances. These products contain harmful substances including phthalates and lead. These are likely to affect the brain and overall health of your baby.

Antimicrobial property

Crib sheets with antimicrobial property are an excellent choice. These help in promoting better health for your newborn. It is because they inhibit the growth of disease-causing organisms. It protects your baby from illnesses like a cough, cold and infection.

It is through preventing the buildup of mold and mildew. When you use crib sheets with antimicrobial property, there is no buildup of odor which might cause bacteria.

Right colors and design

You will find crib sheets in a variety of colors and designs. However, you have to choose according to your child’s gender. Sheets which come in floral patterns or colors like lavender, pink and yellow are for girls. Alternatively, those with animal prints and colors like green and blue are for boys.

Crib sheets which come in neutral colors such as beige and white can work for boys and girls. These also include designs such as stripes and dots. All it takes is to pick the right color for your child.

Safety tips when for crib sheets

  • Mind the way you swaddle the baby to avoid wrapping her too tightly
  • Avoid soft bedding in baby’s crib.
  • Use sheets with a thread count of about 200
  • Colored designs on the bedding have to be printed or woven into the fabric, not stamped on like a screen printed t-shirt.


Crib sheets are an important purchase any parent has to make for their baby. With the myriad of styles, designs, colors, and sizes, it might be a daunting task if you do not have an idea of what you are looking for.

Hope this buyer guide and review has given enough ideas on how to make the right decision. It is now easy for you to sort through a variety of options. You will get sheets to offer the comfort and style your baby needs.

Love this Post? Help Us Spread the Word
Joscelyn Booker

I’m a 30-something wife and working mom of two kids, a boy and a girl. I juggle work, kids’ activities, caring for the family and of course blogging.
I enjoy sharing my thoughts on motherhood. We don’t have to try hard at being perfect mothers.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Reply: